----------------- HES POSTING ----------------- Roger Sandilands reported on Joan Robinson's observation, in 1980, that she "would rather have the grievance" than the Nobel Prize. I remember that she made an almost identical remark in the fall of 1982 when I told her that George Stigler had won the prize--I believe I was the first person she heard the news from. She was a visiting professor (Bernhard Chair) at Williams that semester. I remember distinctly the word "grievance." However, I remember her also saying that she would have liked to have the money so she could donate it to the antinuclear movement. I don't remember her making any comments about Stigler. Roger Bolton Williams College ------------ FOOTER TO HES POSTING ------------ For information, send the message "info HES" to [log in to unmask]