Julio Huato's post [http://eh.net/pipermail/hes/2005-May/003038.html ] is particularly useful, because it puts some deep truths, of the kind I read long ago in Witold Kula's manual (at least the Spanish translation of the Polish, which is now in English) into terms that conventional, uncultured economists might understand. Stll, it seems to me to say more about economic history than about the history of economics (not that these are separate questions). John Womack