I think that others will be interested in our private exchange, which I send with your permission. I would add one point: The entrepreneurial and other activity of which you and others, e.g., Larry Moss, write, can be explained this way: Remember Marx said that profit was a class activity and its distribution a matter of competition within the bourgeois class. So, too, may Ricardian-Georgian rent be seen as something to distribute among land owners via the entrepreneurial activity in your examples. Warren Samuels