Roger Sandilands wrote: "Re Mason Gaffney's shaft at Schumpeter's creative phrase-making, might one not go further? Schumpeter was wrong on the causes of the Great Depression, wrong on what to do about it (nothing), incoherent in his _Business Cycles_ (1939) - Solow called it a "massive failure" - and, I submit, wrong in his view of his great hero, the innovating entrepreneur, and on the dynamics of capitalism." Here's a review of the book by Solow himself: http://www.powells.com/n/219/tnr/review/2007_07_12 Sumitra Shah