Dear Kevin, Thanks. I was aware of the genealogy. It's online via the Internet Archive http://www.archive.org/details/clemensfamilychr00clembut I don't see any relationship in it, anyway, but perhaps I wasn't clear. I'm not actually interested in the degree of relationship, if any, but where and/or how the story started that SLC was, variously, brother, uncle, or cousin to William M. Clemens. It's definitely circulating before 1914. Thanks, Ellen