This has happened before, and probably many more times than we realize, or of which we are aware. A good time, perhaps, to re-visit the Twain/Holmes experience, with a modern day perspective: http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=2202&dat=19871006&id=P8ElAAAAIBAJ&sjid =qvwFAAAAIBAJ&pg=4709,2999324 SLC would have pleaded to "Death by mortification," I think, absent Holmes's graciousness. Roger Durrett Charlotte, NC In a message dated 11/23/2014 4:37:49 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, [log in to unmask] writes: My first thought is that one should not fall for the post-hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. That one passage only preceded the other is no proof the two are related. To evaluate fully this question, one must be fortunate enough to drift over the clear water of Lake Tahoe and gaze downward into its depths as Twain did and later recalled. Looking down from a high vantage point is the only way one can describe this experience. Today, awestruck tourists commonly compare this inspiring sensation to flying on an airplane. In the 19th century, airplanes did not exist, but hot-air balloons did. Lake Tahoe is one of only very few large lakes throughout the world where one can experience this feeling. One might be tempted to conclude that if a passage was plagiarized, it must not be true. However, plagiarism does not mean the subject is untrue, only the culprit author’s personal values are questionable. At worst, Twain might have borrowed the literary treatment, but the accuracy of his observations is indisputable. His description of the offshore distance, size, and geologic classification of the boulders is specific to the North Shore of Lake Tahoe. These conditions only occur within the zone offshore of his campsite on Stateline Point. David C. Antonucci Author of Fairest Picture - Mark Twain at Lake Tahoe