Every time I read about one of these "banning" controversies, I am reminded of Jocelyn Chadwick's excellent essay in _Critical Insights: Adventures of Huckleberry Finn_ (Salem Press, 2017). Chadwick decries such efforts which are undertaken for "children who somehow require the aid of benevolent white and black critics to think and reflect for them." Chadwick further states, "Today's students are proving more than capable of having these hard conversations; indeed, they flourish in them because they want to think and break apart and analyze and understand." A highly recommended essay from an outstanding Mark Twain scholar for any school board wrestling with such issues. Barb