Galbraith describes the micro / macro distinction as ‘one of the
intellectually suffocating errors of modern economics.’
"The point of the analogy between macro and micro economic aspects is
that we can no longer continue with the dangerous notion that these
represent two different realities. Galbraith, attributing this stark
distinction to Keynes, describes it as ‘one of the intellectually
suffocating errors of modern economics.’ (1987:295) One can concur
with Galbraith’s view, since, whatever its author’s intentions, a main
effect of a construct that divides the economy in two in this way is
to give rise to the idea that whatever individuals do and think is not
really important. Indeed, macroeconomics deliberately aggregates and
simplifies this element, encouraging the belief that the big picture
has to be left to governments and experts, and behind them the
wondrous workings of the invisible hand. We should, rather, see the
macro and micro as two ends of a spectrum. Far from referring to
separate worlds, they are two ways of addressing the one reality. "
Galbraith, J.K. (1987) A History of Economics, London: Hamish Hamilton.
FROM: Money, Bookkeeping and the Inherent Ethics of Accounting. 11th
World Congress of Social Economics. Albertville, France, June 2004.
Christopher Houghton Budd
Arthur Edwards
On 16 Jul 2010, at 21:16, Lawrence Boland wrote:
> I am working on a book about model building and wanted to note when
> separate micro and macro classes were first taught. I have asked
> many senior economists starting with Ken Arrow and Dick Lipsey and
> accept for Ken remembering that he taught one in 1949, not much else
> has been uncovered.
>
> I looked at my undergraduate and graduate catalogs but these only
> show recognition in the early 1960 (interestingly, not the earliest
> ones but only in the year I graduated).
>
> The question now is when did separate and explicitly micro and macro
> courses first appear in an economics curriculum (not counting
> business cycles type course)? Obviously in the 1940s in North
> America (but Dick thinks only in the 1950s in Great Britain) -- but
> where and what year? Any ideas? Does anyone have a catalog or
> calendar that lists separate courses in the 1940s?
>
> Regards,
>
> LB
>
>
> --
> Lawrence A. Boland, FRSC
> Department of Economics, Simon Fraser University
> Burnaby BC Canada V5A-1S6
> ph: 778-782-4487, web: http://www.sfu.ca/~boland
|